Skip to main content

Table 3 Challenges of combination drug development and examples of unsuccessful combinations

From: Approaches to modernize the combination drug development paradigm

  Challenges Examples
Target validity and engagement • Discordance between nonclinical and clinical data
• Difficulty characterizing biological relevance and functionality of the target(s), target engagement and modulation by the investigational agent(s), and pathway interactions due to absent or poorly designed pharmacodynamics studies in early clinical studies
Selumetinib (MEK inhibitor) + MK-2206 (AKT inhibitor) in metastatic CRC (phase II)
• Promising nonclinical data
• Target inhibition not consistently reached
• Other potential reasons for failure include possible activation of compensatory mechanisms and overlapping toxicities [129]
Pharmacological effect of drug combination • Effect of drug combinations, which may be additive, synergistic, or antagonistic, has a direct impact on antitumor activity and toxicity
• Often poorly understood in both nonclinical and clinical environments
Adjuvant tamoxifen + anthracycline-based chemotherapy in breast cancer found to be inferior to sequential tamoxifen following chemotherapy (phase III)
• Antagonistic effect suggested by nonclinical data [130, 131]
Patient selection • Being able to accurately select the subgroup of patients who would derive maximal benefit can substantially broaden the therapeutic window. However, identification, validation, and standardization of predictive biomarkers remain very difficult IMC-A12, R1507 or CP-751,871 (IGF-1R inhibitors) + erlotinib (EGFR inhibitor) in metastatic NSCLC in three separate trials (phase I/II, phase II and phase III, respectively)
• Promising nonclinical data
• Three negative studies with limited activity in unselected patients
• No biomarker identified from the studies
• Also poor tolerance seen [132134]
Toxicity • Poor drug tolerance affects the maintenance of dose intensity and duration, thereby limiting efficacy, particularly if two agents share the same target or have overlapping side effects
• Small-molecule TKI combinations may be more likely than mAb combinations to cause increased off-target toxicities and pharmacokinetic interactions via the cytochrome P450 system [65]
Four phase I studies
• Ipilimumab (CTLA-4 inhibitor) + vemurafenib (BRAF inhibitor) led to hepatotoxicity [135]
• Tremelimumab (CTLA-4 inhibitor) + sunitinib (VEGFR inhibitor) led to renal toxity [136]
• Bevacizumab (VEGF inhibitor) + sunitinib led to vascular/hematological toxicities [137]
• Temsirolimus (mTOR inhibitor) + sunitinib led to skin/hematological toxicities [138]
  1. CRC colorectal cancer, mAb monoclonal antibody, NSCLC non-small-cell lung cancer, TKI tyrosine kinase inhibitor